Major Advantages of Chapter 13 for Saving Your Home

If you are behind on your mortgage(s) and/or on other debts on your home, Chapter 13 gives you some tremendous tools for dealing with them.

 

Last week’s blog post was about not filing a Chapter 13 case to save your home when a Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy” would serve you better. Sometimes you don’t need the additional advantages that Chapter 13 provides to keep your home. Or in situations on the other extreme, sometimes even those advantages are not enough to enable you to keep your home.

In that same blog post I introduced five of those Chapter 13 advantages. I’ll just mention them here (partly to entice you to look at what I wrote about them last week). Then I’ll give you five more major ways Chapter 13 helps you with home debts.

The First Five Chapter 13 Advantages

1. More time to catch up on any back mortgage payments.

2. Stripping second or third mortgage.

3. The flexibility that comes from getting extended protection from your mortgage holder(s).

4. A good way to catch up on any back real property taxes.

5. Protect your home from previously recorded and upcoming income tax liens.

6. The Chapter 13 “Super-Discharge”

You can “discharge” (permanently write off) certain very specialized debts in a Chapter 13 case that you cannot in a Chapter 7 one. There are two main kinds of debts that you can only discharge under Chapter 13:

1. obligations arising out of a divorce decree dealing with the division of property and of debt (but NOT the provisions about child/spousal support); and

2. obligations involving “willful and malicious injury” to  property (but NOT bodily injury or death, and not if the injury was related to driving while intoxicated).

So if you owe a significant amount in one of these two unusual kinds of debts, it’s worth considering Chapter 13 as a possible solution.

7. Debts Which Cannot Be Discharged Such as Income Taxes & Back Child/Spousal Support

If you owe any of those special debts which cannot be discharged in bankruptcy, as soon as you finish a Chapter 7 case (usually only about three or four months after you start it) the creditors on those debts can start collecting on them from you. Those particular creditors—such as the IRS, the state taxing authority, the state or local support enforcement agencies, and your ex-spouse—often have extraordinary collection powers. They can put a tax lien or support lien on your home, and under some circumstances can even seize and sell your home to pay those liens.

In great contrast, a Chapter 13 case protects you while you pay off those special debts in a payment plan that you propose and is reviewed and approved by the bankruptcy judge assigned to your case. During the 3-to-5-year plan, all of your creditors—including the ones just mentioned above—are prevented from putting liens on your home. By the completion of your Chapter 13 case those special debts are paid in full or paid current, so that they can’t threaten you or your home any more.

8. “Statutory Liens”: Utility, Contractors, Municipal/Local and Other Involuntary Liens

If you had an involuntary liens imposed by law against your home before you file bankruptcy, those liens would very likely survive a Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

These are called “statutory liens” because they are set up through state statutes, or laws. A utility lien is for an unpaid utility bill. A contractor’s lien (sometimes called a “mechanic’s” or “materialman’s” lien) is for an unpaid, and usually disputed, home remodeling or repair debt. Cities and other local governments can impose a wide variety of fees against your property—such as for failing to keep vegetation trimmed to prevent a fire hazard—which then become liens if not paid.

These liens against your home generally survive a Chapter 7 case, and so these creditors would be able either to threaten foreclosure of your home to force payment, or at least would force payment whenever you’d sell or refinance your home. Under Chapter 13, in contrast, the protection for your home would generally continue throughout the three-to-five year case, keeping it safe while you satisfy the lien.

9. Judgment Lien “Avoidance”

A judgment lien is one that is placed on your home after someone (usually a creditor) sues you, gets a judgment against you, and records that judgment in the county where your home is located (or uses whatever the appropriate procedure is in your state).

In bankruptcy a judgment lien can be removed from your home under certain circumstances, that is, if that judgment lien “impairs” your homestead exemption. The homestead exemption is the amount of equity in your home that the bankruptcy law protects from your creditors. “Impairing” the homestead exemption means that the judgment lien eats into the part of the equity in your home that is protected by the exemption.

Although judgment lien avoidances are available under Chapter 7 as well as Chapter 13, it can often be put to better use in Chapter 13 when used in combination with advantages available only under Chapter 13.

To illustrate with an example, imagine if the amount of home equity that you have in your home would allow you to remove a judgment lien (because that lien eats into equity protected by the homestead exemption), but you are so far behind on your mortgage payments that you would lose your home to a foreclosure by your mortgage lender if you filed a Chapter 7 case. Removing that judgment lien from your home title would be meaningless if you will lose your home to foreclosure. Curing that mortgage arrears under Chapter 13 makes your power to remove the judgment lien worthwhile in a real and practical way.

10.  Protect Equity in Your Home NOT Covered by the Homestead Exemption

With home property values increasing in most parts of the country the last couple years, after major declines during the Great Recession, there are more situations in which the amount of protection provided by the applicable homestead exemption is not enough to cover all the equity.  Most people contemplating bankruptcy probably still don’t have too much equity in their homes. But if you DO have more value in your home than allowed under your homestead exemption, Chapter 13 can protect it unlike a “liquidating” Chapter 7 case.

If you have equity in your home beyond the homestead exemption’s protection, in a Chapter 7 case you run the risk of a Chapter 7 trustee seizing it to sell and pay the unprotected portion of the proceeds to your creditors. Under Chapter 13, in contrast, you can keep the home by paying those creditors gradually over the course of the up-to-five-year Chapter 13 case.

Or you may not want to do that, or you may not have the money in your budget to do that within five years. Then you can sell the home yourself on your own schedule, likely even a few years later, in order to pay the creditors that unprotected portion of the equity, while keeping the homestead exemption amount to put into your next rented or purchased home. In either situation, Chapter 13 leaves you much more in control of your home and your life.

 

/by

When You Should Avoid Using Chapter 13 to Save Your Home

Chapter 13 provides awesome tools for hanging onto your home. Yet sometimes Chapter 7 is enough and better.

 

Chapter 13 and Your Home

Chapter 7—sometimes called “straight bankruptcy—is much simpler and takes much less time than Chapter 13, the version of bankruptcy with a three-to-five-year court-approved payment plan. But Chapter 13 can help in so many ways with home-related debts that people who are behind on their mortgage or have other kinds of liens on their home tend to leap to that option.

In upcoming blogs I’ll talk about all the many ways that Chapter 13 can help. But to give you a taste of them, some of the main ones include:

1. More time to catch up on any back mortgage payments: Chapter 7 gives you a limited amount of time, usually a year at the most, to catch up. Chapter 13 often gives you years, which greatly reduces how much you have to pay each month to eventually get current.

2. Stripping second or third mortgage:  Under Chapter 7 you have to simply pay any junior mortgages. Chapter 13 gives you the possibility of “stripping” a second or third mortgage lien off your home title, potentially saving you hundreds of dollars monthly, and thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars in the long run.

3. The flexibility that comes from getting extended protection from your mortgage holder(s): Chapter 7 gives you at most only about three or four months while your mortgage holder can’t foreclose and your other creditors can’t take action against you or your home. In contrast, under Chapter 13 you could potentially be protected for years. This can often give you creative ways to meet your goals, such as letting you delay selling your home for several years.

4. A good way to catch up on any back real property taxes: Filing a Chapter 7 case doesn’t protect you from property tax foreclosure—beyond the three, four months that the case lasts. Chapter 13 protects you and your home while you gradually catch up on those taxes, in a court-approved plan that also incorporates your mortgage(s) and all other debts.

5. Protects your home from previously recorded and upcoming income tax liens: Chapter 7 usually does nothing to address tax liens that have already been recorded on the home, or to stop future tax liens on income taxes that you continue to owe after the bankruptcy case is completed. In contrast Chapter 13 provides an efficient and effective procedure for valuing, paying off, and getting the release of tax liens. And the IRS/state cannot record a tax lien on income taxes while the Chapter 13 case is active.

That may all sound pretty good (and there’s more). But still, Chapter 13 may be neither necessary nor appropriate in your situation.

Consider Chapter 7 Instead of Chapter 13 When Chapter 7 is Enough

If you are behind on your mortgage payments, but could realistically catch up within about a year, you may not need the stronger medicine of Chapter 13. If you could catch up after writing off all or most of your debts in a Chapter 7 case, and by being financially very disciplined for that one year, that would likely be the wiser way to go.

Most mortgage lenders will negotiate a “forbearance agreement” with you after you file a Chapter 7 case, allowing you to stay in your home and to catch up on your mortgage arrearage by paying a certain amount extra per month. How much time you will have to get current on your mortgage depends on your lender’s practices, your payment history with that lender, and other related factors.

Considering the benefit of getting to your fresh start in a year or so, instead of three to five years, be sure to carefully discuss with your attorney whether solving your mortgage arrearage problem through Chapter 7 looks feasible. Of course also look at all the other advantages and disadvantages of these two options in light of all the rest of your financial circumstances.

Consider Chapter 7 When Chapter 13 Will Not Likely Do Enough

As powerful as Chapter 13 can be, it has its own limitations regarding home debts. For example, it does not have the ability to reduce your first mortgage payment or mortgage balance. It can’t reduce your annual property taxes or discharge (legally write off) any property taxes.  And if you subsequently cannot maintain the payments you agree to in your Chapter 13 plan, you could very well lose the protection against foreclosure and other collection efforts against you.

Especially if your home is under water—you owe on it more than it’s worth—try to think practically about whether the effort to keep the property will be worth the effort. Even if you do have some equity in the property, if you are really going way out on a limb to catch up on the mortgage arrearage and other debts related to the home, carefully consider whether you will really be able to pay what you are arranging to pay. If you pay a bunch of extra money over the course of a year or two only to not be able to maintain the necessary payments and lose the home, you could waste a lot of your time, money, and effort.

As you honestly discuss with your attorney your financial goals, consider whether filing a Chapter 7  case and letting your house go would actually be a better way to meet your (and your family’s) real needs. Chapter 13 should not be a last-ditch long-shot. Be honest with yourself that you may be trying to hang onto a house that you won’t be able to even with all the help that Chapter 13 can provide.

 

/by

Another Five Tremendous Tools to Save Your Home through Chapter 13

These additional 5 tools, especially in combination, can tackle and defeat your mortgage and other home-debt problems.

 

 In my last blog post, I gave you five huge ways that Chapter 13 can save your home. I’ll summarize those briefly here, and then give you and explain another five of them.

Here are the first five. Under Chapter 13 you can:

1. … stretch out payments for catching up on back mortgage payments, as much as five years.

2.   … cur or erase your other debt obligations so that you can afford your mortgage payments.

3. … prevent income tax liens, child and spousal support liens, and judgment liens from every attaching to your home.

4. … pay the debts that cannot be discharged (legally written off) in bankruptcy while being protected from those creditors putting liens on or enforcing liens against your home.

5. … get rid of debts owed to creditors which could otherwise put and enforce liens on your home.

And here are today’s additional five Chapter 13 benefits for your home:

6. … avoid paying all or some of your second (or third) mortgage.

This is the powerful “mortgage strip” that can save you hundreds of dollars a month and sometimes many tens of thousands of dollars over the time you live in your home.

If—and only if—the value of your home is no more than the balance of your first mortgage, your second mortgage can be treated as an unsecured creditor. If so, you can “strip” that second mortgage off the title of your home. This means you can stop making the monthly payments on it. The entire amount that you owe is added to your pool of other unsecured creditors, which are all paid only as much as you can afford to pay over the life of your three-to-five-year Chapter 13 case. And then at the end of the case whatever has not been paid is completely discharged at the end of the case.

Although property values have increased in the last couple of years, there are still millions of homes “under water”—owing more debt than they are worth—and many of these are worth less than their first mortgage.  If this applies to you, it may be reason enough to do a Chapter 13 case. You can usually end up paying only pennies on the dollar—or sometimes even nothing—on your second (or third) mortgage. This leaves your home both much easier to hang on to and much closer to not being “under water.”

7. … get more time to pay property tax arrearage, while protecting your home from both tax and mortgage foreclosure.

If you have fallen behind on your property taxes, this creates two problems. First, you risk losing your home to a property tax foreclosure by the county or whatever other governmental entity is collecting the tax. Second, since your mortgage lender requires you to keep current on your property taxes and considers you falling behind as an independent violation of your mortgage agreement, this gives your lender a separate reason for IT to foreclose on your home.

So Chapter 13 gives you time to catch on your property taxes while both protecting you from the property taxing entity itself and preventing your mortgage lender from using your unpaid property taxes as a separate reason for foreclosing on your home.

8. … prioritize paying many home-related debts—such as property taxes, support liens, utility and construction liens—that you need to and often wish you were able to pay.

Neither Chapter 7 nor Chapter 13 enables you to simply get rid of these special kinds of liens on your home. But Chapter 13 allows—indeed often requires—you to pay them in full ahead of most of your other creditors. This often benefits you because it allows you to focus your limited financial resources on paying those debts which will preserve and add equity to your home.

9. … get rid of judgment liens, so that they no longer attach to your home.  

If a creditor sues you and you don’t respond by the deadline to do so, the creditor will get a judgment—a court determination that you owe whatever the creditor’s lawsuit says you owe. Most of the time that judgment creates a judgment lien against your home. Depending on a number of factors like the value of your home, the amount of your mortgage(s) and other liens, the amount of the judgment lien, and the amount of the homestead exemption that you are entitled to, bankruptcy will allow you to “void”—get rid of—that judgment lien. This is very important because otherwise even if the underlying debt is discharged, the judgment lien would survive the bankruptcy, causing you to still have to pay the debt eventually, in part or in full.   

If you qualify for judgment lien “avoidance” it can also be done under a Chapter 7 case, but it is often better in a Chapter 13 case when used in combination with these other tools.

10. .. sell your house without the pressure of a foreclosure sale, either just a short time after filing the Chapter 13 case, or sometimes even three, four years later.

If you are close to selling your home, or have just started the process but want to sell as soon as you can, Chapter 7 usually buys you very little time in avoiding a pending foreclosure. It gives you very little leverage or flexibility. In these situations, Chapter 13 will usually buy you more time to sell while preventing foreclosure. And, especially if you have some equity in your home, it will give you more payment flexibility.

Or if you want to sell your home a few years from now, Chapter 13 can give you some very valuable flexibility in catching up on a mortgage arrearage. You may be planning on downsizing once your children finish high school or you reach some other important life event. Or you may want to wait until property values increase over the next couple years. Under Chapter 13 you can often put off catching up on some or all of your mortgage arrearage until that anticipated sale date, making it more financially feasible to keep your home in the meantime.

 

/by

Five Tremendous Tools to Save Your Home through Chapter 13

Powerful Chapter 13 gives you tools to solve your mortgage and other home lien problems from a number of different angles. 

 

The Limits of Chapter 7 “Straight Bankruptcy”

In my last blog I described how a Chapter 7 case can under certain circumstances help you enough to save your home. Or in other situations it can at least help you delay a foreclosure for as long as you need.  But Chapter 7 can only give limited help, maybe enough if you aren’t too far behind on your mortgage circumstances, or you don’t have other kinds of lienholders causing problems.

The Extraordinary Tools of Chapter 13

Chapter 13, on the other hand, provides you a range of much more powerful and flexible tools for solving many, many debt issues so that you can keep your home.

Here are the first five of ten significant ways that Chapter 13 can save your home (with the other five to come in my next blog).

Under Chapter 13 case you can:

1.  stretch out the amount of time for catching up on back mortgage payments for as long as 5 years. This is in contrast to the one year or so that most mortgage lenders will give you to catch up if you do a Chapter 7 case instead. This longer period can greatly lower your monthly catch-up payments, making more likely that you would succeed in actually catching up and keeping your home. Very importantly, throughout this catch-up period your home is protected from foreclosure as long as you stay with the payment plan, one that you propose. Within limits you can later modify that plan if your circumstances change.

2. slash your other debt obligations so that you can afford your mortgage payments. The mortgage debt—especially your first mortgage—can’t be significantly changed under Chapter 13. So you are usually required to pay your full monthly mortgage payment, and to catch up any arrearage, but to accomplish this you are allowed to pay to most of your other debts.

3.  permanently prevent income tax liens, and child and spousal support liens, and such from attaching to your home. The “automatic stay” preventing such liens under Chapter 7 last usually only about 3 months, and there’s no mechanism for dealing with these kinds of debts. Instead under Chapter 13, these liens are prevented throughout the three-to-five-year length of the case.

4.  have the time to pay debts that can’t be discharged (legally written off) in bankruptcy, all the while being protected from those creditors attacking your home. So even if a tax or support lien is already in place before you file, you are given the opportunity to pay the debt while under the protection of the bankruptcy laws. That undercuts the leverage of those liens against your home. Then by the end of your case, the debts are paid and those liens are released.

5.  discharge (write off) debts owed to creditors which could otherwise attack your home. For example, certain (generally older) income taxes can be discharged, leaving you owing nothing. But had you not filed the Chapter 13 case, or delayed doing so, a tax lien could have been recorded, which would have required you to pay some or all of the balance to free your home from that lien. Even most standard debts can turn into judgment liens against your house once you are sued and a judgment is entered. Depending on the facts, a judgment liens may or may not be able to be gotten rid of in bankruptcy.  If instead you file a Chapter 13 case to prevent these liens from happening, at the end of your case the debt is gone, and no such liens attach to your home.

See my next blog post for the other five house-saving tools of Chapter 13.

 

/by

When a Chapter 7 “Straight Bankruptcy” Helps You Enough on Your Home

A 3-to-5-year Chapter 13 case is often the right tool if you are behind on mortgage payments. But sometimes the simpler Chapter 7 is enough.

 

Chapter 13 Is a Powerful Package

If you want to keep your home but are behind on your mortgage payments, a Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts” is often what you need. It comes with an impressive set of tools to address many home debt problems. It gives you more time to catch up on the mortgage, may enable you to “strip” a second or third mortgage off your title, and gives you very helpful ways for dealing with property taxes, income tax liens, judgment liens, and such.

When Chapter 7 is Enough  

But what if you have managed to fall only a few months behind on your mortgage, and could afford the payments if you just got relief from your other debts?

Or what if you aren’t even keeping the house, but do need a little more time to find another place to live?

Then you may not need a Chapter 13 case, and could save the extra time and cost that it would take compared to Chapter 7. In the right situations Chapter 13 is highly worthwhile because of what it can do. But if you don’t need those advantages, Chapter 7 may be adequate and appropriate.

Buying Just Enough Time for What You Need

The “automatic stay”—the bankruptcy provision that stops virtually all actions by creditors against you or your property—applies to Chapter 7 just as it does to Chapter 13.  So the filing of a Chapter 7 case stops a foreclosure just as quickly as a Chapter 13 filing.

But Chapter 7 usually buys you much less time than a Chapter 13 could.

If you are not very far behind on your mortgage payment(s) and want to keep your home, when you file a Chapter 7 case your mortgage lenders will usually give you several months to catch up on your back payments. You must immediately start making your regular monthly payments, if you had not been making them, and must enter a strict schedule for catching up on the arrearage. In return the lender agrees to hold off foreclosing, as long as you make the payments as agreed.

If instead you are not keeping the house but just need to have more time to save money for moving into a rental home, a well-timed Chapter 7 case will buy you more time in your house. During that time you don’t pay mortgage payments, enabling you to get together first and last month’s rent payment, any necessary security deposit and other moving costs.

The tough-to-answer question is how much extra time would a Chapter 7 filing give you. It mostly depends on how aggressive your mortgage company is about trying to start or restart the foreclosure efforts.  A pushy lender could, soon after you file your case, ask the bankruptcy court for “relief from the stay”—permission to start or restart the foreclosure process. If so, then your bankruptcy filing would buy you only an extra month or so.

Or on the other extreme, a mortgage lender could potentially take no action during the 3 months or so until your Chapter 7 case is finished. At that point the “automatic stay” protection expires, and the lender can start or restart the foreclosure. Or it may sit on its hands even longer. During the height of the mortgage crisis a few years ago, mortgage lenders were so backed up and so reluctant to foreclose, that many homeowners were living in their homes without making payments for a year or two! That is mostly a thing of the past but it goes to show how open-ended this situation can be at times.

Your bankruptcy attorney will likely have some experience in how aggressive your particular mortgage lender is under facts similar to yours.

Stopping Dangerous Liens Against Your Home

Chapter 7 prevents potential liens from being placed against your home, especially important when the lack of a lien makes all the difference. This can occur with IRS and state tax liens and judgment liens. A timely filing of a Chapter 7 case could result in paying nothing on a debt vs. paying it in part or in full.

Consider the example of an older IRS debt that meets the conditions for discharge (legal write-off in bankruptcy), in a situation in which you have equity in your home but no more than would be protected under the homestead exemption. If you did not file a bankruptcy until after the IRS recorded a tax lien for that debt against your house, that lien would continue being attached to your house in spite of your bankruptcy. You would have to pay the tax debt in order to get the lien released when you sold or refinanced the house.

However, if your Chapter 7 case was instead filed before the IRS recorded a tax lien, the “automatic stay” would prevent that tax lien from being recorded, the tax debt would be discharged and never have to be paid.

Discharge Other Debts So You Can Afford to Pay Your Mortgage Payments

Chapter 7 allows you to focus your financial resources on your house payments by getting rid of your other debts.

If you’ve managed to keep current on those mortgage payments, but fear you can’t continue to do so because of financial pressure from other debts, the relief you get from discharging those other debts can allow you to stay in your home long term.

Or you may have missed only a few mortgage payments, AND, after discharging your other debts, can reliably make future monthly payments plus enough extra to catch up on your arrearage within year or less. If so, then Chapter 7 would like likely do enough for you. Most mortgage creditors will make arrangements with you –called a “forbearance agreement”—to catch up the missed payments by paying a sufficient specific amount extra each month until you’re caught up, as long as that catch-up time is relatively short.

However, if after discharging your other debts you could not catch up on your arrearage within about a year, you may well need the extra firepower of Chapter 13 to buy you more time.

 

/by

Are These Sensible Reasons to Do A Short Sale? Maybe, Maybe Not

Let’s look at some commonsensical reasons to do a short sale of your home and see if they make sense.

 

My last blog post showed how a short sale may be harder to achieve than you might think, and how they can be dangerous if you do it without advice from an attorney looking out for you.

So today we follow up by looking more closely at why you would do a short sale. Besides probably the most common one of simply trying to avoid the bad credit of a foreclosure, which we addressed last time, here are some other common reasons:

1. No Choice, Can’t Afford the House

If your income has gone down or your mortgage payments have gone up so that you can’t keep making the payments, it may make sense to downsize—sell your home and rent. And if you can’t sell your home because it’s worth less than the mortgage balances, then a short sale may seem to be the only way to leave the home and its debt behind.

However…

Monthly rental payments have climbed significantly in the last several years as more people have lost their homes to foreclosures, and less young people have been able to afford or qualify for a mortgage because of the tough employment market and skyrocketing student loan debt.  Demand has outstripped the supply of rental housing in many markets, greatly increasing the cost to rent.

Also, you have many legitimate tangible and intangible reasons to stay in your home. If you leave this home it may be a long time before you would have the financial means to buy again, especially with the tighter credit standards that are likely to be in place for years. Property values in many parts of the country have gone up significantly in the last year or two and seem to be on a trajectory to continue doing so. So you may be building equity in your home soon. And your family may benefit from staying in your home for deep personal reasons—to maintain family stability, to avoid leaving your kids’ school district, and such.

So if there would be a way that you would be able to afford your home, that way would be worth considering carefully.  

2.  Can’t Reduce House Mortgage Payments, Right?

It’s true that you are largely stuck with whatever your monthly first mortgage payment amount is. And if you are behind on those payments, you will have to catch up if you want to keep your home.

However…

If you have a second (or third) mortgage, you may be able to “strip” that mortgage off your home’s title so that you would not need to make that mortgage’s monthly payments. This can happen under a Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts” if your home is worth less than the balance of your first mortgage, so that there is no equity at all in your home for the second mortgage.

By “stripping” this second mortgage from your home, your debt on that mortgage debt would be treated as an unsecured debt, just like all of the rest of your conventional unsecured debts (credit cards, medical bills and such). This means you would pay that mortgage debt during your 3-to-5 year Chapter 13 case as much, but only as much, as you could afford to pay on it, which is often not much—sometimes even nothing. Then at the end of the case, whatever has not been paid by then is discharged–legally written off completely.

As a result you avoid having to pay the monthly second mortgage payments, and the debt against your home is significantly reduced. These—along with the other benefits of Chapter 13—can potentially make hanging onto your home both financially feasible in the short term and financially much more sensible in the long term. You would pay less each month for a home with much less debt on it.

3.  Needing to Resolve Other Liens

You may feel compelled to do a short sale not just because of your mortgage obligations, but because of one or more other obligations which have attached to your home’s title, with a tax, judgment, support, utility, or construction lien.

You may be under a great deal of pressure to pay one or more of these obligations. The IRS, state tax, and child support enforcement agencies can be especially aggressive. So you could understandably feel that you have no choice but to sell your home to get that aggressive creditor paid, and to sell by short sale if necessary.

The problem is that the more lienholders you have, the more creditors must be corralled into accepting less than their full balance in return for releasing their lien on your home. And even if the special lienholder releases its lien for less than full payment so that the short sale succeeds, you will continue owing the balance, and likely continue being pursued for payment.

However…

Either Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy can often deal well with each of these kinds of lienholders. Both may be able to “void” judgment liens. Chapter 13 is particularly adept at attacking tax and support liens and their underlying debts. Furthermore, you can be protected for years from any further collection efforts by these otherwise very powerful creditors, in ways that no other legal procedure could accomplish.

Conclusion

Bankruptcy options often give you more control over your home and over your financial life than would occur through a short sale. Given what’s at stake, it certainly makes sense to consult an attorney about your options. Your attorney is on your side, legally and ethically bound to explain all your options as they relate to your personal goals and your best interests.

 

/by

Short Sales of Your Home–Sometimes Necessary, Often End Not As You Expected

A short sale might be your best alternative. But they can be hard sales to close, and may not accomplish what you hope.

 

Someone Doesn’t Get Paid

In a short sale, you sell your house by “shorting”—underpaying—one or more of the lienholders, because the sale price is not enough to pay everyone in full.

In the depths of the recent real estate crash, a large percentage of home sales were short sales because the value of so many houses had fallen below what was owed on them. Even though property values have climbed in many parts of the country, there are still millions of homes “under water,” and so can only be sold in a short sale.

Why Short Sales Are Harder to Close

You can imagine that if a mortgage holder or someone else has a lien on your home and a legal right to be paid in full, it will be reluctant to take anything less than payment in full before releasing its lien. And these lienholders can include not just voluntary ones like your first and maybe second mortgage, but also judgments, income taxes, support obligations, unpaid utilities, and property taxes. Generally all lienholders must consent and release their liens, or the sale cannot occur.

Their Benefits

Beyond getting out of a house that you can’t afford, the main benefit of a successful short sale is that it avoids a foreclosure on your credit record. Although in general that is a sensible goal, a short sale is also likely detrimental on your credit record—after all you are not paying one or more of your creditors in full. Also, given how many millions of foreclosures occurred in the last 5-6 years, there is some indication that there is and will continue to be less credit record difference between a short sale and a foreclosure. Depending on the rest of your credit record, now and in the future, focusing on avoiding foreclosure may not be as important as you may think.=

Short Sales Often Do Not Come Together

Most short sales take much more effort and time to pull off than expected, so they usually take longer, and then often fail to close, putting the homeowners further behind and no better off. The reasons they often don’t work are:

  • Unhelpful and slow mortgage lenders: In a short sale usually the first mortgage holder has to give some money from the sale proceeds to a junior lienholder or two. The only reason the first mortgage holder would do that is if getting a little less out of the sale is better than going through the delay and cost of a foreclosure. Although many mortgage lenders have gotten better organized and staffed to process short sales, working with them can still be like pulling teeth.
  • Any lienholders can refuse to cooperate and kill the deal: When the pie that is too small, it’s hard to make everybody happy and cooperative. Any lienholder can refuse to take the proposed reduction in payment and jeopardize the closing.
  • The realtors and other middlemen often have the most to gain: Realtors and others in the real estate sales industry often benefit more from a short sale than you do. There are good reasons that unbiased observers—like bankruptcy judges—tend to discourage short sales.

Short Sales Can Be Dangerous

You could end up legally liable to those lienholders who were not paid in full, and could also potentially owe extra income taxes.

  • Unpaid balances on the junior mortgages and liens: You may be told that you will not be liable on debts that aren’t paid in full from the home sale, but that’s not always true. You need to be sure that the settlement documents and the applicable law in fact cut off any liability. Be careful about feeling forced to accept some remaining liability just to get the deal done.  
  • Potential tax consequences: This issue is a complicated one that can’t be covered here in adequate detail. The main point is that debt forgiveness can be treated as income subject to taxation unless you fit within one of the exceptions. Make sure you talk with an appropriate tax specialist about this before investing any time or expectations in the short sale option.  

Short sale attempts often fit two wise rules of thumb: 1) desperate actions often lead to no good, and 2) if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

 

/by

If You File a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy with an Attorney You are Nearly Ten Times More Likely to Reach Your Goal of Writing Off Your Debts

Here’s some hard evidence on why it’s dangerous to file bankruptcy without an attorney.

 

As a bankruptcy attorney, I get many phone calls from people who have tried to file a bankruptcy by themselves and have gotten into trouble, sometimes serious trouble. I also run into similar horror stories about what happens when people file without an attorney when I attend “meetings of creditors”—the usually straightforward, usually short meeting with the bankruptcy trustee that everyone filing bankruptcy must attend. I’ve run into countless example of how dangerous it is to file bankruptcy without an attorney.

But I HAVE wondered whether anybody has actually investigated this question. Now somebody has, and we have some pretty solid evidence to back up what I have been witnessing anecdotally.

“The Do-It-Yourself Mirage: Complexity in the Bankruptcy System”

That is the title to a chapter in a book about bankruptcy called Broke: How Debt Bankrupts the Middle Class. This book is a series of articles about many important current issues in the field, with this one chapter focusing on cases filed by debtors not represented by attorneys (“pro se” filers).

The author of this chapter, Asst. Professor Angela K. Littwin of the University of Texas School of Law, analyzed data from the Consumer Bankruptcy Project, “the leading [ongoing] national study of consumer bankruptcy for nearly 30 years.” Her finding: “pro se filers were significantly more likely to have their cases dismissed than their represented counterparts.”

Very interestingly, she also learned from the data that

consumers with more education were significantly more likely than others to try filing for bankruptcy on their own, but that their education didn’t appear to help them navigate the process. Pro se debtors with college degrees fared no better than those who had never set foot inside a college classroom.

She concluded that after bankruptcy law was significantly amended back in 2005 in an effort to discourage as many people from filing, “bankruptcy has become so complex that even the most potentially sophisticated consumers are unable to file correctly.”

Ten Times More Likely to Get a Discharge of Your Debts

In a closely related study, Prof. Littwin stated that “17.6 percent of unrepresented [Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy”] debtors had their cases dismissed or converted” into 3-to-5-year Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts” cases.  “In contrast, only 1.9 percent of debtors with lawyers met this fate.”  Even after controlling for other factors such as “education, race and ethnicity, income, age, homeownership, prior bankruptcy, whether the debtor had any nonminimal unencumbered assets at the time of the filing,” “represented debtors were almost ten times more likely to receive a discharge than their pro se counterparts.”

Prof. Littwin concluded that “filing pro se dramatically escalates the chance that a Chapter 7 bankruptcy will not provide a person with debt relief.”

 

/by

The Expenses Step of the Chapter 7 “Means Test”

If your income is higher than “median income,” you may still file a Chapter 7 case by going through the expenses step of the means test.

 

The Easy, Income Step of the Means Test

The last couple of blog posts have covered the first step of the means test, the income step. It says that if your “income”—as that term is uniquely defined in this law—is no more than the published median amount for your state of residence and for your size of family, you can skip the rest of the means test, and you generally qualify for a Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy” case. You don’t have to go through the rest of the means test.

The Admittedly Complicated, Expenses Step of the Means Test

If on the other hand your “income” is greater than the median income amount applicable to your state and family size, then you have to go through the detailed expenses step to see whether you can participate in a Chapter 7 case.

The Challenge of the Means Test

The concept behind the means test is pretty straightforward: people who have the means to pay a meaningful amount to their creditors over a reasonable period of time should be required to do so. But putting that concept into law resulted in an amazingly complicated set of rules.

These expense rules are detailed and rigid because Congress was trying to be objective. The assumption was debtors would just inflate their anticipated expenses to show that they had no money left over for their creditors—no “means” to pay them anything.

One of the complications is that the allowed expenses include some based on your stated actual expense amounts, while others are based on standard amounts. The standard amounts are based on Internal Revenue Service tables of expenses, but some of those standards are national, some vary by state, and some even vary among specific metropolitan areas within a state. There are even some expenses which are partly standard and partly actual (certain components of transportation expenses).

There are also rules about when to allow and how to determine the allowed amounts for secured debt payments (vehicle, mortgage) and for “priority debts” (income taxes, accrued child support).

If You Have Disposable Income

After all that, if after subtracting all the allowed expenses from your “income” you have some money left over, whether you can be in Chapter 7 depends on the amount of that money and how that compares to the amount of your debts:

  1. If the amount left over—the “monthly disposable income”—is no more than $125, then you still pass the means test and qualify for Chapter 7.
  2. If your “monthly disposable income” is between $125 and $208, then apply the following formula: multiply that amount by 60, and compare that to the total amount of your regular (not “priority”) unsecured debts. If the multiplied total is less than 25% of those debts, then you still pass the means test and qualify for Chapter 7.
  3. If after applying the above formula you can pay 25% or more of those debts, OR if your “monthly disposable income” is more than $208, then you do NOT pass the means test, UNLESS you can show “special circumstances,” such as “a serious medical condition or a call or order to active duty in the Armed Forces.”

THAT’s Complicated!

True enough. So you certainly want to have an attorney who fully understands these often confounding rules and how they are being interpreted by the local bankruptcy judges and the pertinent appeals courts.

If you don’t pass the means test you will instead likely end up in a 3-to-5-year Chapter 13 case. Not only would that mean getting full relief from your debts years later than under Chapter 7, with a similar delay in rebuilding your credit, you may well also end up paying thousands, or even tens of thousands, more dollars to your creditors. It’s definitely worth going through the effort to find a competent bankruptcy attorney to help you, whenever possible, find a way to pass the means test. 

 

/by

Taking Advantage of the Rigidity of the Chapter 7 “Means Test”

Because of how precisely the amount of your “income” is calculated, filing bankruptcy just a day or two later can make all the difference.

 

Passing the “Means Test”

Our last blog post was about most people passing the “means test” by making no more than the median income for their state and family size. We also made clear that “income” for this purpose has a very broad meaning, by including non-taxable received from irregular sources such as child and spousal support payments, insurance settlements, cash gifts from relatives, and unemployment benefits. Also, we showed how time-sensitive the “means test” definition of “income” is in that it is based on the amount of money received during precisely the 6 FULL CALENDAR months before the date of filing. This means that your “income” can shift by waiting just a month or two, or even by waiting just a few days until the turn of the month (since that changes which 6 months of income is at issue).

Why is the Definition of “Income” for the “Means Test” So Rigid?

One of the much-touted goals of the last major amendments to the bankruptcy law in 2005 was to prevent people from filing Chapter 7 who were considered not deserving. The most direct means to that end was to try to force more people to pay a portion of their debts through Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts” instead of writing them off Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy.”

The primary tool intended to accomplish this is the “means test,” Its rationale was that instead of allowing judges to decide who was abusing the bankruptcy system, a rigid financial test would determine who had the “means” to pay a meaningful amount to their creditors in a Chapter 13 case, and therefore could not file a Chapter 7 case.

The Unintended Consequences of the “Means Test”

The last blog post explained the first part of the means test: comparing the income and money you received from virtually all sources during the six full calendar months before filing bankruptcy to a standard median income amount for your state and your family size. If your income is at or under the applicable median income, then you generally get to file a Chapter 7 case. If your income is higher than the median amount, you may still be able to file a Chapter 7 case but you have to jump through a whole bunch of extra hoops to do so. Having income below the median income amount makes qualifying for Chapter 7 much simpler and less risky.

Filing your case a day earlier or later can matter so much because of the means test’s fixation on the six prior full calendar months, AND because you include ALL income during that precise period (other than social security). 

So if you receive some irregular chunk of money, that can push you over your applicable median income amount, and jeopardize your ability to qualify for Chapter 7.  

An Example

It does not necessarily take a large irregular chunk of money to make this difference, especially if your income without that is already close to the median income amount. An income tax refund, some catch-up child support payments, or an insurance settlement or reimbursement could be enough. 

Imagine having received $3,000 from one of these sources on October 15 of last year. Your only other income is from your job, where make a $42,000 salary, or $3,500 gross per month. Let’s assume the median annual income for your state and family size is $45,000.

So imagine that now in the early part of April 2014, your Chapter 7 bankruptcy paperwork is ready to file, and you would like to get it filed to get protection from your aggressive creditors. If your case is filed on or before April 30, then the last six full calendar month period would be from October 1, 2013 through March 31, 2014. That period includes that $3,000 extra money you received in mid-October. Your work income of 6 times $3,500 equals $21,000, plus the extra $3,000 received, totals $24,000 received during that 6-month period. Multiply that by 2 for the annual amount—$48,000. Since that’s larger than the applicable $45,000 median income, you would have failed the income portion of the “means test.”

But if you just wait to file until May 1, then the applicable 6-month period jumps forward by one full month to the period from November 1 of last year through April 30 of this year. Now that new period no longer includes the $3,000 you received in mid-October. So now your income during the 6-month period is $21,000, multiplied by 2 is $42,000. This results in your income being less than the $45,000 median income amount. You’ve now passed the “means test,” and qualified for Chapter 7. 

 

/by