Chapter 13 Handles Both Older and Newer Income Tax Debts

If you owe a few years of income taxes, Chapter 13 lets you write off those that can be, while giving you time to pay those that must be.

 

Our Example

The last blog post introduced an example of how Chapter 13 can be a particularly good way to handle income tax debts when you owe multiple years of taxes. In that example:

  • Without a bankruptcy, a couple would have to pay about $30,000 to the IRS for back taxes, plus about another $45,000 in medical bills and credit cards, a total of about $75,000. Given their modest income and resulting ability to pay these obligations only very slowly, this couple would almost certainly be subject to many years of collection efforts, lawsuits and garnishments until the obligations were paid off.
  • Under Chapter 13, this same couple would pay only about $18,000—36 months of $500 payments. That’s less than 1/4th of the above $75,000 amount—and substantially less than the taxes alone!. Furthermore, the couple’s monthly payments would be based on their ability to pay. During this payment period their creditors—including the IRS—would be prevented from taking any collection action against them.

How Does Chapter 13 Work to Save So Much on Taxes and Other Debts?

  • Tax debts that are old enough are grouped with the “general unsecured” debts—such as medical bills and credit cards. These are paid usually based on how much money there is left over after paying other more important debts. This means that often these older taxes are paid either nothing or only a few pennies on the dollar.
  • The more recent “priority” taxes DO have to be paid in full in a Chapter 13 case, along with interest accrued until the filing of the case. However: 1) penalties—which can be a significant portion of the debt—are treated like “general unsecured” debts and thus paid little or nothing, and 2) usually interest or penalties stop when the Chapter 13 is filed. These can significantly reduce the total amount that has to be paid.
  • “Priority” taxes—those more recent ones that do have to be paid in full—are all paid before anything is paid to the “general unsecured” debts—the medical bills, credit cards, older income taxes and such. In many cases this means that having these “priority” taxes to pay simply reduces the amount of money which would otherwise have been paid to those “general unsecured” creditors. As a result, in these situations having tax debt does not increase the amount that would have to be paid in a Chapter 13 case, which is after all based on what the debtors can afford. In our example, the couple pays $500 per month because that is what their budget allows. That’s the same amount they would have to pay even if they owed nothing to the IRS! The couple meets their obligations under Chapter 13 by having most of their plan payments go to the IRS recent tax debts, and likely nothing to their other creditors or older IRS debts.
  • The bankruptcy law that stops creditors from trying to collect their debts while a bankruptcy case is active—the “automatic stay”—is as effective stopping the IRS as any other creditor. The IRS can continue to do some very limited and sensible things like demand the filing of a tax return or conduct an audit, but it can’t use the aggressive collection tools that the law otherwise grants to it. Gaining relief from collection pressure from the IRS AND all the rest of the creditors is one of the biggest benefits of Chapter 13.

Deciding Between Chapter 7 and 13 for Income Taxes

If, unlike the example, all of the taxes were old enough to meet the conditions for discharging them under Chapter 7, there would be no need for a Chapter 13 case. On the other hand if more “priority” tax debts had to be paid than in the example, the debtors would have to pay more into their Chapter 13 plan, either through larger monthly payments or for a longer period of time.

There are definitely situations where it is a close call choosing between Chapter 7 or Chapter 13. And sometimes preparing an offer in compromise with the IRS—either instead of or together with a bankruptcy filing—is the best route. To decide which of these is best for you, you need the advice of an experienced bankruptcy attorney to help you make an informed decision and then to execute on it.  

 

/by

The Four Conditions for Writing Off Income Taxes in Bankruptcy

The conditions for writing off income tax debts actually make sense.

 

The last blog introduced the four conditions for discharging (legally writing off) taxes in bankruptcy. Here’s a fuller explanation of them.

The Core Principle Behind the Four Conditions

There is a simple principle behind all four of these conditions: under bankruptcy law taxpayers should be able to write off their tax debts just like the rest of their debts, AFTER the IRS (or other tax authority) has a reasonable length of time to try to collect those taxes.

What’s a reasonable length of time in the eyes of the law? How much of an opportunity do the tax authorities have to collect before you can discharge the tax debt?

The four conditions each measure this amount of time differently, based on the following:

1) when the tax return for the particular income tax was due,

2) when the tax return was actually filed,

3) when the tax was “assessed,” and

4) whether the tax return that was filed was honest and therefore reflected the right amount of tax debt when it was filed.

To discharge an income tax debt, it must meet all four of these conditions.

Here they are in order:

1) Three Years Since Tax Return Due:

All income taxes have a fixed due date for its return to be filed. That date may be delayed by a certain number of months if you asked for an extension, but it’s still a specific point in time. This first condition gives the tax authorities three years from the tax return filing date, or from the extended filing date if you asked for an extension. Note that this is fixed date, not affected by when you actually filed the return nor by what the tax authority did once it received the tax return.

2) Two Years Since Tax Return Actually Filed:

This second condition is different than the first because it is a time period triggered by your own action, your filing of the tax return.

Note that you can file a tax return late and still be able to discharge the debt if at least two years have passed since you filed the return. (Caution: there are some parts of the country where some court opinions have questioned this—be sure to talk with your attorney about the law in your jurisdiction.)

3) 240 Days Since Assessment:

This third condition can be a bit confusing. It very seldom comes into play—most tax debts meet this condition without any problem.

Assessment is the tax authority’s formal determination of your tax liability. It usually happens in a straightforward way, when it receives, processes, and accepts your tax return.

Most of the time an income tax is assessed within a few days or weeks that it is received. So the period of time of 240 days after assessment usually passes long before the above three-years-since-the-return-is-due or two-year-since-tax-return-filed time periods. But the law has to account for the less common situations when the assessment is delayed. These situations can involve a lengthy audit, or litigation, or an “offer-in-compromise” (a taxpayer’s formal offer to settle). In these kinds of situations the three-year and two-year periods may have passed before the official assessment of the tax, and so the tax authority still has 240 days once assessment is made to pursue that tax debt.

4) Fraudulent tax returns and tax evasion:

This last condition effectively means that the above time periods are not triggered at all if you are intentionally dishonest on your tax return or try to avoid paying the tax in some other way. In those situations the tax authority has no opportunity even to begin collecting the tax. So, if you don’t meet this condition, you cannot discharge the tax no matter how old it is.

If your tax debt meets these four hoops, you should be able to discharge that tax in either a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

If You Don’t Meet These Conditions

But what if you owe taxes which do not meet these four conditions, and so can’t be discharged? What if some of your taxes can be discharged by meeting these conditions but some of them don’t? Or what if the IRS or the state tax authority has recorded a tax lien? What if your tax debt arises from your operation of a business? What if you owe not income taxes but some other type of tax? The next few blog posts will get into these questions. 

 

/by

The Persistent Myth About Taxes and Bankruptcy

Many people believe that bankruptcy can’t write off any income taxes. Even attorneys sometimes perpetuate this myth.


Occasional Attorney Misinformation

The following dialog was found on a video of a bankruptcy attorney’s website showing the attorney being interviewed. In response to a question by the interviewer whether there were some debts that can’t be “touched” in a bankruptcy, the attorney responded:  

“Absolutely. Things like child support, alimony, uh, tax debts, student loans. Those generally aren’t dischargeable.”

The interviewer: 

“So the government’s gonna help you eliminate some of the debt in a bankruptcy. But not the debt to them.”

The attorney quipped:

“Not theirs, of course!”

Putting tax debts in the same category as child support and alimony—which indeed cannot ever be legally written off, or discharged—is wrong because income taxes CAN be discharged, as soon as they are old enough.

It is at the very least highly misleading for the attorney to say that tax debts “generally aren’t dischargeable” while including it with support debts that are never dischargeable, or student loans which are very rarely dischargeable.

Upcoming Answers about Taxes and Bankruptcy

Through the next few blog posts, you’ll learn what taxes can be discharged and what can’t. The fact is that bankruptcy can discharge taxes of many types and in many situations. Sometimes ALL of a taxpayer’s taxes can be discharged, or most of them. But there ARE significant limitations, which I will explain carefully.

Bankruptcy Can Help Deal with Taxes in Many Ways Beyond Potentially Writing Them Off

Besides the possibility that you will be able to discharge some or all of your taxes, bankruptcy can also:

1. Stop the tax authorities from garnishing your wages and bank accounts, and levying on (seizing) your personal and business assets.

2. Prevent them from gaining greater leverage against you, through tax liens and cumulating penalties and interest.

3. Avoid being forced to pay monthly payments directly to the tax authorities, with the monthly amounts dictated without sufficiently considering your other legal obligations and reasonable living expense.

Overall, bankruptcy gives you unique leverage against the IRS and/or your state/local tax authority. It gives you a lot more control over a very powerful class of creditors. Your tax problems are resolved not piecemeal but rather as part of your entire financial package. So you don’t find yourself focusing on your taxes while worrying about the rest of your creditors. 

 

/by