Posts

Chapter 13 Handles Tough Income Tax Debts

If you owe recent income taxes, or multiple years of taxes, Chapter 13 can provide huge advantages over Chapter 7, and over other options.

 

This blog post will illustrate this with an example, which will be more fully explained in my next blog.

The Example

Consider a husband and wife with the following scenario:

  • Husband lost his job in 2008, so he started a business, which, after a few promising years in which it generated some income, failed in late 2012.
  • The wife was consistently employed throughout this time, with pay raises only enough to keep up with inflation.
  • They did not have the money to pay the quarterly estimated taxes while husband’s business was in operation, and also could not pay the amount due when they filed their joint tax returns for 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012. To simplify the facts, for each of those five years they owe the IRS $4,000 in taxes, $750 in penalties, and $250 in interest. So their total IRS debt for those years is $25,000—including $20,000 in the tax itself, $3,750 in penalties, and $1,250 in interest.
  • Husband found a reliable job six months ago, although earning 20% less than he did at the one he lost before he started his business.  
  • They filed every one of their joint tax returns in mid-April when they were due, and have been making modest payments on their tax balance when they have been able to.
  • They have no debts with collateral—no mortgage, no vehicle loans.
  • They owe $35,000 in medical bills and credit cards.
  • They can currently afford to pay about $500 a month to all of their creditors, which is not nearly enough to pay their regular creditors, and that’s before paying a dime to the IRS.
  • They are in big financial trouble.

Without Any Kind of Bankruptcy

  • If they tried to enter into an installment payment plan with the IRS, they would be required to pay the entire tax obligation, with interest and penalties continuing to accrue until all was paid in full.
  • The IRS monthly payment amount would be imposed likely without regard to the other debts they owe.
  • If the couple failed to make their payments, the IRS would try to collect through garnishments and tax liens.
  • Depending how long paying all these taxes would take, the couple could easily end up paying $30,000 to $35,000 with the additional interest and penalties.
  • This would be in addition to their $35,000 medical and credit card debts, which could easily increase to $45,000 or more when debts went to collections or lawsuits.
  • So the couple would eventually end up being forced to pay at least $75,000 to their creditors.

Under Chapter 13

  • The 2008 and 2009 taxes, interest and penalties would very likely be paid nothing and discharged at the end of the case. Same with the penalties for 2010, 2011, and 2012. That covers $11,500 of the $25,000 present tax debt.
  • The remaining $13,500 of taxes and interest for 2010, 2011, and 2012 would have to be paid as a “priority” debt, although without any additional interest or penalties once the Chapter 13 case is filed.
  • Assuming that their income qualified them for a three-year Chapter 13 plan, this couple would likely be allowed to pay about $500 per month for 36 months, or about $18,000, even though they owe many times that to all their creditors.
  • This would be enough to pay the $13,500 “priority” portion of the taxes and interest, plus the “administrative expenses” (the Chapter 13 trustee fees and your attorney fees).
  • Then after three years of payments, they’d be completely done. The “priority” portion of the IRS debt would have been paid in full, but the older IRS debt and all the penalties would be discharged (written off), likely without being paid anything. So would the credit card and medical debts.

After the three years, under Chapter 13 the couple would have paid a total of around $18,000, instead of eventually paying at least $75,000 without the Chapter 13 case. They’d be done—debt-free—instead of just barely starting to pay their mountain of debt. And they would have not spent the last three years worrying about IRS garnishments and tax liens, lawsuits and harassing phone calls, and the constant lack of money for necessary living expenses.

The next blog post will show how all this works.

 

/by

The Persistent Myth About Taxes and Bankruptcy

Many people believe that bankruptcy can’t write off any income taxes. Even attorneys sometimes perpetuate this myth.


Occasional Attorney Misinformation

The following dialog was found on a video of a bankruptcy attorney’s website showing the attorney being interviewed. In response to a question by the interviewer whether there were some debts that can’t be “touched” in a bankruptcy, the attorney responded:  

“Absolutely. Things like child support, alimony, uh, tax debts, student loans. Those generally aren’t dischargeable.”

The interviewer: 

“So the government’s gonna help you eliminate some of the debt in a bankruptcy. But not the debt to them.”

The attorney quipped:

“Not theirs, of course!”

Putting tax debts in the same category as child support and alimony—which indeed cannot ever be legally written off, or discharged—is wrong because income taxes CAN be discharged, as soon as they are old enough.

It is at the very least highly misleading for the attorney to say that tax debts “generally aren’t dischargeable” while including it with support debts that are never dischargeable, or student loans which are very rarely dischargeable.

Upcoming Answers about Taxes and Bankruptcy

Through the next few blog posts, you’ll learn what taxes can be discharged and what can’t. The fact is that bankruptcy can discharge taxes of many types and in many situations. Sometimes ALL of a taxpayer’s taxes can be discharged, or most of them. But there ARE significant limitations, which I will explain carefully.

Bankruptcy Can Help Deal with Taxes in Many Ways Beyond Potentially Writing Them Off

Besides the possibility that you will be able to discharge some or all of your taxes, bankruptcy can also:

1. Stop the tax authorities from garnishing your wages and bank accounts, and levying on (seizing) your personal and business assets.

2. Prevent them from gaining greater leverage against you, through tax liens and cumulating penalties and interest.

3. Avoid being forced to pay monthly payments directly to the tax authorities, with the monthly amounts dictated without sufficiently considering your other legal obligations and reasonable living expense.

Overall, bankruptcy gives you unique leverage against the IRS and/or your state/local tax authority. It gives you a lot more control over a very powerful class of creditors. Your tax problems are resolved not piecemeal but rather as part of your entire financial package. So you don’t find yourself focusing on your taxes while worrying about the rest of your creditors. 

 

/by

Priority Debts in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

Chapter 13 can be a stronger and more flexible tool for dealing with priority debts than Chapter 7.

The last blog explained how sometimes Chapter 7 can be a good tool to pay or reduce your priority debts. Priority debts are ones specially designated in bankruptcy law to be treated better than you ordinary debts.

For consumers, the most common priority debts are back child/spousal support payments and taxes. But as the last blog showed, you need to have a relatively unusual “asset” Chapter 7 case, meaning that you need to have an asset or assets that is not protected—not exempt—that you would surrender to the trustee.

It helps if when that asset is sold by the trustee the sale proceeds would be enough to pay off your priority debts, after paying any costs of sale (such as a broker’s commission) and the trustee’s fee.

Chapter 13 is much more likely to apply to your circumstances if you owe a bunch of priority debts.

Here are some ways that it is better than Chapter 7, and better than trying to pay your priority taxes or back support without any bankruptcy.

1. Be protected from the priority creditors: Tax authorities and state support agencies have been provided by law with extraordinarily aggressive collection powers against you. These often include the ability to seize your assets; garnish your wages, bank accounts, and business receivables without additional court proceedings; suspend your driving and occupational/professional licenses, and even hunting and fishing licenses.

Some of these collection efforts can even continue when you file a Chapter 7 case, and all can continue as soon as your Chapter 7 is completed, giving you just a three month or so break. In contrast, Chapter 13 stops virtually all of these collection efforts, so long as you comply with the terms of your payment plan, as well as keep current going forward.

2. Stop further accumulating interest and penalties: Usually in a Chapter 13 case, the interest and penalties on priority debt stops being added, and then is discharged at your successful completion of your case. If you have large income tax debt, this can significantly reduce the amount you would pay.

3. Get a more sensible budget: Your monthly obligation under Chapter 13 tends to be based on more realistic expenses than what the IRS or your support enforcement agency will allow..

4. Allows you to favor the priority debt over other debt: Usually you are able to and indeed must pay your priority debt ahead of and often instead of your “general unsecured creditors.” So you are able to concentrate your financial efforts on paying off the debts that are usually in your self-interest to pay anyway.

/by

What Are Priority Debts and Why Are They Important?

You may or may not know that all of your debts are not all treated equally in bankruptcy.

Most debts can be “discharged” (legally written-off), but some can’t be, or only in certain situations. Some debts have no collateral—they are unsecured—while other debts are secured by collateral.

A secured debt can be treated differently depending on how much the collateral is worth compared to the amount of the debt it secures, and depending on whether you intend to surrender or retain the collateral.

A handy starting point in understanding debts in bankruptcy is to divide all debts into three categories: secured debts, unsecured debts, and “priority” debts. Today’s blog is on this last category.

Priority debts are a list of special debts which Congress has decided deserve special treatment, and in certain circumstances should get paid through your bankruptcy case ahead of other debts.

For consumers this priority list only comes into play with “asset” Chapter 7 cases and with Chapter 13 cases. This blog will cover the “asset” Chapter 7 cases; the next one will cover Chapter 13.

10 Different Priority Debts

There are 10 different priority debts. They are listed in the Bankruptcy Code in order of priority. So not only do priority debts usually get paid in a bankruptcy case before debts that are not priority debts, the priority debts themselves get paid in the order that they show up on the list.

Most of the 10 different kinds of priority debts are not applicable to a conventional consumer bankruptcy. But two of them are quite common: 1) child and spousal support arrearage, and 2) tax debts of various kinds. The support debt is listed as a higher priority than taxes, and indeed is the highest one on the entire list.

Most Chapter 7 cases are “no asset” ones—all your assets are protected from creditors through “exemptions,” so you keep everything you own and nothing goes to the Chapter 7 trustee to distribute to your creditors.

But in an “asset” Chapter 7 case you own something that is not covered by any exemption, so the trustee can take, sell, and distribute its proceeds to your creditors.

If you have a particular “non-exempt” asset, perhaps something that you do not mind surrendering to the trustee, and if you owe a priority debt, a Chapter 7 case can be way to turn these to your benefit.

Most priority debts are not dischargeable in a Chapter 7 case—such as support arrearage and most debts—so it’s beneficial to have the trustee use your unprotected asset as the means to paying off or paying down a support arrearage or tax.

Here’s an illustration. Assume you own a boat free and clear with a marketable value of $4,000 that you admit that you can’t afford to keep any longer, it is not exempt, and so you would surrender it to your Chapter 7 trustee.

You owe $1,000 in last year’s income taxes, plus $2,000 in back child support. Theoretically you could have sold the boat before filing bankruptcy and paid the taxes and support, but you may not have time if you were trying to stop a garnishment or some other creditor action.

In this case, the Chapter 7 trustee would sell the boat, pay herself a trustee fee (25% of the first $5000 collected, so $1,000 here), pay first the support obligation and then the tax debt. If the boat indeed sold for $4,000, you would finish your Chapter 7 case owing neither of those priority debts, and hopefully with all your other debts discharged.

You can see by this illustration that a carefully planned Chapter 7 can be a good tool in these kinds of situations.

/by